Re-enactment: "stayed until closing, left at 2:30"

From lisamarieyoung.ca
Revision as of 04:29, 4 December 2023 by Arielmais (talk | contribs) (init)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)

Summary

The Crime Stoppers re-enactment video erroneously states that Lisa stayed at the bar until closing, and left around 2:30am. In actuality, Lisa left The Jungle at about 1:00am.

Prologue

Load video
Local File
Watch our video: RCMP vs Crime Stoppers (more info)

In 2003, RCMP spokesman[1] Const. Jack Eubank claimed that Crime Stoppers no longer produced re‑enactment videos[2] — a statement which was later proven to be a blatant lie.[3] This is one of several false or misleading statements made by Eubank and other RCMP members regarding Lisa's disappearance.[4]


Learn more → RCMP said: "Crime Stoppers no longer makes re‑enactments".


Load video
Local File
Crime Stoppers 2009 re‑enactment video depicting Lisa's disappearance[5] (source)

In 2009 the re-enactment video was finally produced by Nanaimo & District Crime Stoppers with ShawTV[6], based on details provided by Nanaimo RCMP investigators.[3][5] Unfortunately, most of the information presented was wrong.[7]


See all 18 inaccuracies → RCMP misinformed Crime Stoppers for re‑enactment.


Detail

"stayed until closing, left at 2:30" — clip from re‑enactment produced in 2009, based on largely-inaccurate details provided by RCMP. Animated GIF (Source)[5]

At 0m32s in the Crime Stoppers' re‑enactment video, narrator RCMP Cst. Gary O'Brien mistakenly states that Lisa stayed at the bar until closing, and left around 2:30am..

The fact is, Lisa and Dallas left The Jungle with Adair in his grandmother's Jaguar XJ-40 at 1am.[8][9]

Bar closing time

The Crime Stoppers statement seems to imply that the bar closed at 2:30am when, in reality, the bar would not have been open past 2:00am — and the RCMP would have clearly been aware of this fact.

An October 2002 report commissioned by the City of Nanaimo confirms that The Jungle had a Class 'C' liquor license (cabaret/nightclub) which means they must close by 2:00am, and includes an RCMP statement about incidents occurring when groups of nightclub patrons (19 to 25 year olds) exit the area's Class 'C' establishments at 2:00am when the establishments close.[10]


The re-enactment video was produced based on details provided to Crime Stoppers by Nanaimo RCMP investigators.[3]


See Also

Sources

  1. ↑ Fort McMurray Today (July 10, 2002), Foul play suspected in missing B.C. woman (source)
  2. ↑ Paul Walton, Nanaimo Daily News (May 29, 2003), When sadness turns to anger (source)
  3. ↑ 3.0 3.1 3.2 Ruth Olgilvie, Ha-Shilth-Sa (Aug 14, 2003), Investigation for missing woman frustrates family (source)
  4. ↑ lisamarieyoung.ca "Lisa's List of Fifty"
  5. ↑ 5.0 5.1 5.2 Shaw TV, YouTube (May 15, 2009), Lisa Marie Young - Crime Stoppers (video) (source)
  6. ↑ Nanaimo Daily News (May 6, 2009), Still unsolved (source)
  7. ↑ lisamarieyoung.ca "List of inaccuracies in the Crime Stoppers re‑enactment"
  8. ↑ This is first-hand information from the author — and was reported to the lead investigator.
  9. ↑ Glenna Burns, Kawartha Promoter (July 12, 2018), "On a healing journey" kp20180712
  10. ↑ Neilson-Welch Consulting City of Nanaimo (October 11, 2002), "City of Nanaimo Liquor Control Strategy" PDF
Retrieved from "https://lisamarieyoung.ca/w/index.php?title=Re-enactment:_%22stayed_until_closing,_left_at_2:30%22&oldid=1853"