RCMP misinformed Crime Stoppers for reenactment
From lisamarieyoung.ca
Summary
When Crime Stoppers produces re-enactment videos, the content is based exclusively on information provided by police investigators. In 2009, Nanaimo RCMP finally sent Crime Stoppers the information they needed to produce a re-enactment about Lisa's disappearance. Unfortunately, most of the information investigators provided was wrong.
An official RCMP spokesman initially claimed that "Crime Stoppers no longer makes re-enactments".
This was later determined to be a blatant lie.[1]
This was later determined to be a blatant lie.[1]
Videos
Details
# | Time | Error | Correction |
---|---|---|---|
34 | 0m 19s | "…Lisa was at various nightclubs…" | The Jungle was the only club Lisa went to that night.[2] (This has never been disputed by anyone, including police, except for here.) |
35 | 0m 25s | "…Lisa & her friends entered…" | Lisa entered the bar alone,[3] after the conversation with Adair.[4] (Lisa's female friends left, and Dallas stayed outside with Adair.)[5] |
36 | 0m 32s | "…stayed until closing, left at 2:30…" | Lisa and Dallas left The Jungle with Adair in the Jaguar at 1am.[3][4] |
37 | 0m 38s | "…after close, she talked with several friends…" | The conversation outside took place upon Lisa's arrival at The Jungle.[5] |
38 | 0m 41s | "…Lisa's friend struck up a conversation…" | Adair, who was standing nearby, overheard and joined the conversation.[5] |
39 | 0m 45s etc. |
"…older model Red Jaguar…" | The Jaguar was maroon, as reported by the media in numerous articles.[6] (Investigators know this; they seized the car for forensic inspection.)[1]
|
40 | 0m 58s | "…gladly accepted his offer…" | Lisa declined the offer repeatedly before entering The Jungle, but was urged several times before (feeling obligated) finally agreeing to leave.[3][5] |
41 | 1m 02s | "…the 5 of them…" | Only Lisa and Dallas went with Adair in the Jaguar.[3] |
42 | 1m 07s | "…Westwood Lake area…" | The 2nd party was in the Cathers Lake area.[7] (There has never been any other mention of Westwood Lake other than here.) |
43 | 1m 14s | "…Lisa was hungry…" | Adair offered to buy food for the group, if Lisa would come to help him with it.[5] |
44 | 1m 35s | "…last time anyone has ever seen Lisa…" | Obviously Adair saw her (as he was driving the car she was in) as did others, later. |
45 | 1m 41s | "…reported missing several days later…" | Joanne contacted RCMP less than 8 hours later.[8] (This is especially insulting to Lisa's parents: it took days for RCMP to take her disappearance seriously.) |
46 | 1m 45s | "…exhaustive search…by Nanaimo RCMP…" | By the video's 2009 release date, RCMP had searched one location.[9] |
47 | 2m 15s | "…call Crime Stoppers…" | The lead RCMP investigator has been specifically telling the public not to call Crime Stoppers.[3][10](Which is it, and Why?) |
48 | 2m 20s | "Missing since: June 30th, 2002" | Lisa was last seen July 1st, 2002[2][3] (as stated at the beginning of the video). |
49 | 0m 23s etc. |
Depiction of Lisa's outfit | Lisa was wearing black leather thigh-high boots and a metal chain of silver hoops.[3] The chain is listed on the RCMP's dossier.[2] The chain & boots are both mentioned in several media articles.[11] (Both will be significant in recovery of her remains.) |
50 | 0m 39s etc. |
Depiction of Adair | Adair is inaccurately depicted as a "tough guy": muscular and wearing a tank top, but witnesses described him as "preppy".[9][12]
|
51 | 0m 45s etc. |
Depiction of Lisa's friends | Lisa's friends are shown to consist of 3 males. In reality, other than Dallas, all of Lisa's friends were female.[3][5][9] |
See Also
- RCMP said "Crime Stoppers no longer makes re-enactments" — a blatant lie[1]
- Timeline: July 1, 2002
- RCMP vs Crime Stoppers
- ▶ Watch the video "LISA: RCMP vs CRIME STOPPERS" on YouTube or locally
- Inaccuracies published in the RCMP's dossier for Lisa's case
Sources
- ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 Ruth Olgilvie, Ha-Shilth-Sa (Aug 14, 2003),
Investigation for missing woman frustrates family
hss20030814 - ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 Govt of Canada, RCMP (Jun 26, 2019),"Official Dossier: Lisa Marie Young" — ARCHIVE.ORG JUN 2019
- ↑ 3.0 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6 3.7 This information was obtained first-hand by the author. ✎ Sworn declaration can be provided as needed.
- ↑ 4.0 4.1 Glenna Burns, Kawartha Promoter (July 12, 2018),
On a healing journey
kp20180712 - ↑ 5.0 5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 5.5 This information was provided directly to the author by a credible, reliable source who was present. ✎ Sworn declaration can be provided as needed.
- ↑ Paul Walton, Nanaimo Daily News (Sep 10, 2002),
Tips spark new search for woman
ndn20020910 - ↑ Vancouver Sun (Feb 26, 2011),
Nanaimo RCMP appeal for help
vs20110226 - ↑ Paul Walton, Nanaimo Daily News (July 10, 2002),
Police fear local met with foul play
ndn20020710 - ↑ 9.0 9.1 9.2 MP Paul Manly, Parliament, Ottawa (Oct 8, 2020),
House of Commons Debate #12 - October 8, 2020 (43-2) at 1525
hoc20201008 - ↑ Cyndy Hall on behalf of Cpl. Muntener, Facebook (Feb 3, 2021), "Lisa Marie Young - Cyndy Hall photos" fb20210203
- ↑ Denise Titian, Ha-Shilth-Sa (May 15, 2012),
Family seeks closure 10 years after daughter's disappearance
hss20120515 - ↑ Animated GIF: comparison of Adair's appearance to that of the actor used to portray him. File:CS-adair-compare.gif
Pages in category "RCMP misinformed Crime Stoppers for reenactment"
The following 20 pages are in this category, out of 20 total.
R
- Re-enactment: "after close, she talked with several friends"
- Re-enactment: "call Crime Stoppers"
- Re-enactment: "exhaustive search by Nanaimo RCMP"
- Re-enactment: "gladly accepted his offer"
- Re-enactment: "last time anyone has ever seen Lisa"
- Re-enactment: "Lisa & her friends entered"
- Re-enactment: "Lisa was at various nightclubs"
- Re-enactment: "Lisa was hungry"
- Re-enactment: "Lisa's friend struck up a conversation"
- Re-enactment: "Missing since: June 30th, 2002"
- Re-enactment: "older model Red Jaguar"
- Re-enactment: "reported missing several days later"
- Re-enactment: "stayed until closing, left at 2:30"
- Re-enactment: "the 5 of them"
- Re-enactment: "Westwood Lake area"
- Re-enactment: depiction of Adair
- Re-enactment: depiction of Lisa's friends
- Re-enactment: depiction of Lisa's outfit
Media in category "RCMP misinformed Crime Stoppers for reenactment"
This category contains only the following file.
-
Crimestoppers-reenactment.mp4 ; 13.29 MB